In a significant move that could reshape the digital news landscape in New Zealand, Google has announced that it will cease linking to local news articles and terminate its agreements with news organizations if the government proceeds with a proposed law mandating fair payment for content. This decision reflects ongoing tensions between tech giants and news publishers over revenue-sharing frameworks, sparking a debate about the future of journalism in the digital age.
Context of the proposed legislation
The New Zealand government, under the leadership of the Labour Party, has been pushing for legislation that ensures fair revenue sharing between digital platforms and media organizations. This initiative was confirmed in July and aims to address the growing concerns among news publishers about the financial disparities that arise from the increasing dominance of tech companies in the news distribution ecosystem. The legislation, currently under review, is expected to undergo amendments to align it more closely with Australian laws, which have faced scrutiny and praise since their introduction.
Caroline Rainsford, the Country Director for Google New Zealand, expressed the company’s grave concerns regarding the proposed bill in a recent blog post. She stated that if the legislation is enacted in its current form, Google would be compelled to implement substantial changes to its services, which could ultimately limit access to news content for New Zealand users.
Google’s stance and concerns
Rainsford emphasized that the implications of the proposed law extend beyond just business interests. “We’d be forced to stop linking to news content on Google Search, Google News, or Discover surfaces in New Zealand and discontinue our current commercial agreements and ecosystem support with New Zealand news publishers,” she noted. This declaration raises alarm bells for many who rely on these platforms for news and information.
The tech giant’s concerns center on several critical points. Firstly, Google argues that the legislation contradicts the foundational principle of an open internet, potentially restricting access to diverse news sources for users. Secondly, the company believes that the proposed uncapped financial liabilities could create uncertainty for smaller publishers, which may be detrimental to the overall media landscape. This sentiment reflects a broader apprehension within the industry about how such legislation could affect not just large players but also independent and regional news organizations.
Government response and industry consultation
New Zealand’s Minister for Media and Communications, Paul Goldsmith, acknowledged the diverse opinions within the sector regarding the proposed law. He stated, “We are still in the consultation phase and will make announcements in due course.” Goldsmith has been actively engaging with various stakeholders, including Google, to discuss their concerns and gather insights into how the legislation could impact the news industry.
Despite the opposition from the minority coalition partner ACT, there seems to be a likelihood of garnering enough cross-party support to pass the legislation once it is finalized. The government appears committed to striking a balance that addresses the needs of news publishers while considering the implications for digital platforms.
More Read
A global perspective
The proposed legislation in New Zealand echoes a similar law enacted in Australia in 2021, which granted the government authority to compel internet companies to negotiate content supply deals with media outlets. This move was aimed at ensuring fair compensation for news organizations whose content appears on these platforms. A review conducted by the Australian government in 2022 found that the law had been largely effective, suggesting a model that New Zealand might seek to emulate.
Implications for the future
The potential fallout from Google’s decision to withdraw news links could have significant ramifications for the New Zealand media landscape. As the country navigates the intersection of traditional journalism and digital platforms, the outcome of this legislation will likely set a precedent for how tech companies interact with news publishers globally.
As the consultation process continues, all eyes will be on the New Zealand government to see how they respond to the concerns raised by Google and other stakeholders. The outcome could redefine the relationship between tech giants and news media in New Zealand, and potentially influence similar discussions worldwide.
The unfolding events emphasize the importance of a balanced approach that fosters a thriving media ecosystem while recognizing the role of digital platforms in shaping how news is consumed in the modern era.
