Peers urge urgent visa reforms to attract global STEM talent as Immigration White Paper nears release
Members of the House of Lords have voiced grave concerns over the UK’s current visa regime, warning that its complexity and high costs are discouraging world-class scientists and researchers from coming to Britain. As the Government prepares to unveil its long-awaited Immigration White Paper next week, peers from the Lords Science and Technology Committee have urged swift action to avoid falling behind in the global race for STEM expertise.
In a strongly-worded letter addressed to the Prime Minister, Home Secretary, Chancellor, and Science Minister, committee chair Lord Robert Mair argued that Britain’s current approach is “damaging the national interest” and in stark contrast to the proactive strategies adopted by key international competitors.
“There is a rare opportunity to rectify a system that places unnecessarily high barriers in front of skilled individuals who want to live and work in the UK,” Lord Mair wrote. “At a time of rapid technological change and intensifying geopolitical uncertainty, our choices now will shape the country’s future. Business as usual is simply not an option.”
The committee’s concerns are grounded in data showing that the number of visas granted for science, engineering and research roles dropped by nearly a third in the second half of 2024, compared to the same period the previous year.
The Lords highlighted the example of the United States, where many scientists have been seeking to relocate in the wake of the Trump-era funding cuts. Nations such as France, Germany, and Canada have responded by launching bespoke programmes to attract STEM professionals. Yet, the UK, burdened by prohibitively expensive visa costs—among the highest globally—risks losing out.
The Lords’ intervention comes as the Government, under increasing pressure from Reform UK’s strong performance in recent local elections, prepares to double down on its commitment to reducing net migration. According to ministers, the upcoming Immigration White Paper will detail how Labour plans to bring immigration numbers down, in line with pledges made in their manifesto.
But Lord Mair was keen to stress that attracting skilled science and technology professionals was entirely compatible with Labour’s overall goal of reducing migration. “Global Talent visas account for only around 4,000 people per year—less than 1% of the net migration figures for 2024. Excluding these individuals from our workforce is a false economy,” he said.
More Read
As part of its broader immigration crackdown, the Government is also reportedly considering further restrictions on visa applications from countries with high rates of asylum claims, including Pakistan, Nigeria, and Sri Lanka. The Home Office is said to be developing a risk profile to identify applicants deemed most likely to overstay or claim asylum after entering on work or student visas.
Recent figures released by the Home Office show a sharp drop in visa applications for NHS and care sector jobs—attributed to new eligibility requirements imposed earlier this year. However, this has coincided with a record surge in asylum applications. A total of 108,138 people applied for asylum in 2024—the highest annual number since records began in 2001.
A Home Office spokesperson defended the Government’s stance, stating: “To tackle abuse by foreign nationals who arrive on work and study visas and go on to claim asylum, we are enhancing intelligence gathering to detect trends and act swiftly.”
They added: “We keep the visa system under constant review. Our upcoming Immigration White Paper will outline a clear and comprehensive plan to bring order to a broken system and ensure the UK’s immigration policy serves the national interest.”
Nevertheless, the Lords’ warning adds to growing unease in the academic and scientific communities, with many fearing that without urgent reform, Britain risks shutting itself off from the innovation and expertise it so desperately needs.
