US Elections 2024: Can Trump Become the Second President to Serve Non-Consecutive Terms?
As the 2024 U.S. presidential race heats up, former President Donald Trump, the 45th president, is campaigning to reclaim the Oval Office. Having referred to his time out of office as merely a “pause,” Trump is eyeing a return to the White House, hoping to be the only president besides Grover Cleveland to serve two non-consecutive terms.
A unique historical precedent
While many presidents have attempted a comeback campaign after leaving office, only one has succeeded in reclaiming the presidency after an intervening term: Grover Cleveland, who served as both the 22nd and 24th president of the United States. Cleveland’s first term spanned from 1885 to 1889, but he lost his re-election bid to Republican Benjamin Harrison in 1888. In an era of intense political rivalry and evolving party dynamics, Cleveland’s loss came after a contentious campaign, and like Trump in 2020, he also faced accusations of voting irregularities.
However, Cleveland didn’t retire his political ambitions entirely. After seeing the results of the 1890 midterm elections, in which his Democratic Party gained ground, he decided to run again in 1892. His supporters pushed him to challenge Harrison, and his reputation as a fiscal conservative, combined with discontent over Harrison’s “billion-dollar Congress,” helped Cleveland win the election and return to office in 1893. Today, Cleveland remains the only president with non-consecutive terms, holding a unique place in American history as both the 22nd and 24th president.
The re-election attempts that fell short
Trump’s re-election effort aligns with a long history of former presidents attempting to regain the White House, most of whom ultimately failed. Among them were Martin Van Buren in 1844 and 1848, Millard Fillmore in 1856, Ulysses S. Grant in 1880, and Theodore Roosevelt in 1912. Roosevelt’s bid, especially, was remarkable: he created his own “Bull Moose” party to challenge his successor, William Howard Taft, but his campaign divided the vote, allowing Woodrow Wilson to secure the presidency.
Although these former presidents may have remained popular among certain groups, they lacked the broad support necessary to return to power. Each candidate faced unique political and social obstacles, and their efforts remind us that reclaiming the presidency is no simple feat.
Cleveland’s second term challenges
Though Cleveland regained the presidency, his second term was marked by immense challenges, particularly the economic depression of 1893, which remains one of the most severe downturns in U.S. history. This depression led to widespread unemployment, business closures, and hardship, and it dampened Cleveland’s popularity. His commitment to fiscal conservatism made it difficult for him to implement large-scale relief measures, and his reliance on the gold standard and other economic policies alienated parts of his political base. Nevertheless, Cleveland emerged from his second term with a reputation for steadfast integrity, earning respect as an elder statesman and a symbol of fiscal responsibility.
Trump’s Bid: A parallel to Cleveland?
Trump’s re-election campaign comes amid numerous legal challenges, including accusations of attempting to overturn the 2020 election. Unlike Cleveland, whose campaign was largely boosted by his party, Trump has encountered mixed support within the Republican Party. Nonetheless, he has maintained a solid base and continues to receive backing from prominent Republican figures and a considerable portion of the conservative electorate. His campaign’s focus on issues such as immigration, economic conservatism, and critiques of what he calls “the Washington establishment” resonates with many voters.
More Read
Yet, Trump’s journey toward another term differs from Cleveland’s in key ways. The political climate in 2024 is highly polarized, with Trump’s presence in the race heightening both enthusiasm among his supporters and opposition from his critics. His ongoing legal battles, some tied to events surrounding the Capitol riots of January 6, 2021, and his efforts to contest the results of the 2020 election, add layers of complexity to his campaign. While Cleveland focused on financial reform and restraint, Trump’s campaign has pivoted towards strong rhetoric on immigration and critiques of current U.S. foreign policy.
Could Trump defy the odds?
As the election draws near, Trump stands at a crossroads. History shows that non-consecutive presidential terms are rare and challenging, with Cleveland remaining the only success story in this regard. Trump’s attempt will test whether his core message of “America First” can draw enough support to overcome the opposition he faces. While his base remains committed, winning the broader electorate may prove a more formidable task, as evidenced by the controversy surrounding his legal and political battles.
If he does succeed, Trump would join Grover Cleveland in the history books, marking another chapter in the evolving story of American politics. However, should he lose, he would join a long list of former presidents who found that winning back the White House was ultimately out of reach. As political analysts watch the campaign unfold, Trump’s path to a second, non-consecutive term appears uncertain, a testament to both the power of incumbency and the unpredictability of American democracy.
