Culture Secretary Lisa Nandy has suggested that wealthier households could pay more to fund the BBC, as the Government explores alternatives to the current flat-rate licence fee.
In an interview with the PA news agency, Ms Nandy said she was open to discussions about a more progressive model after BBC chairman Samir Shah proposed a sliding scale of payments. Mr Shah, who took over as chairman in March last year, recently told The Sunday Times: “Why should people who are poor pay the same as people in wealthy households?”
Ms Nandy echoed this sentiment, emphasising the need for fairness in how the BBC is funded. “We are keen that whatever we do in the charter review commands broad public support and that it is progressive,” she said.
She also highlighted concerns over the impact of the current system on low-income households, particularly vulnerable women who have faced prosecution for failing to pay the licence fee. “The licence fee is a flat rate. It’s harder for poorer households to pay it, and we’ve seen some horrendous cases where the BBC has prosecuted mainly vulnerable women for not paying the licence fee. We think that’s completely unacceptable,” she added.
Reviewing the licence fee model
The BBC’s royal charter is up for review, and the Government has pledged to consider alternative ways to fund the public broadcaster. However, Ms Nandy has ruled out general taxation as a funding model, arguing that it would make the BBC too susceptible to political interference.
She stressed the importance of public involvement in the debate, saying: “I think it’s too early to be speculating about the right approach. I think it’s important that both the BBC and the Government are respectful of the fact that this has to be a public conversation.”
“The BBC doesn’t belong to the Government or the BBC; it belongs to the people of this country, and they have to be central to the conversation about how we safeguard its future, not just for the next decade but well into the latter half of this century.”
Rising costs and BBC funding challenges
The Government has already committed to increasing the licence fee in line with inflation until 2027. This means the annual charge will rise from £169.50 to £174.50 next month.
More Read
This increase comes after a period in which the licence fee was first frozen and then raised at a slower rate than the BBC had anticipated. As a result, the broadcaster has faced increasing financial strain, leading to cuts in services and programming.
Alternative funding models have been suggested, including a subscription-based system similar to those used by streaming services. However, Mr Shah has dismissed this idea, arguing that it “would not meet the BBC’s key role to offer something for everyone in the country.”
A fairer future for BBC funding?
The debate over the licence fee is set to intensify in the coming months as the Government’s charter review progresses. Advocates for reform argue that a fairer payment system is needed to ensure that the BBC remains accessible to all, while critics warn that changing the model could threaten the broadcaster’s independence and universality.
While Ms Nandy has not committed to a specific alternative, her comments suggest that a move towards a means-tested or tiered system could be on the table. The challenge now lies in finding a solution that balances fairness with the need to sustain one of the UK’s most important public institutions.
For now, the future of BBC funding remains uncertain, but one thing is clear—change is coming.
